Understanding the difference between what dogs can digest and what they actually need
One of the most persistent debates in canine nutrition revolves around a seemingly simple question: Are dogs carnivores or omnivores? And perhaps more importantly, what does their evolutionary history tell us about what we should be feeding them today?
We often hear that dogs should eat like wolves because they descended from wolves. On the other hand, commercial pet food advocates frequently point to the dog's ability to digest carbohydrates as evidence that grains and other starches belong in their diet.
As is often the case with biology, the answer is considerably more nuanced.
An interesting article by Carol Beuchat, PhD, published by the Institute of Canine Biology in 2018, explores one of the genetic changes that occurred during canine domestication: an increased ability to digest starch.¹ The research offers a fascinating look at how dogs adapted to living alongside humans, but it also raises an important distinction between what an animal is capable of digesting and what constitutes an optimal diet for that animal.
How Domestication Changed Canine Digestion
Dogs and wolves share a common evolutionary ancestry, but thousands of years of domestication have resulted in some significant biological differences. One of these differences involves a gene called AMY2B, which is responsible for producing pancreatic amylase, an enzyme that helps break down starch into smaller sugars during digestion.
Wolves and several other wild canids typically possess two copies of this gene. Domestic dogs, however, often have substantially more. Some individuals have more than 20 copies. This genetic variation matters because dogs with additional copies of AMY2B generally produce more pancreatic amylase, giving them a greater capacity to digest starch efficiently.
In other words, many domestic dogs have evolved digestive capabilities that differ from those of their wild ancestors.
But why would this adaptation have occurred?
Agriculture Played an Important Role
As humans began developing agricultural societies, the diets of the dogs living alongside them changed as well.
Rather than relying exclusively on hunting, humans increasingly cultivated grains and raised livestock. Dogs living in these communities consumed whatever foods were readily available, which often included grains, dairy products, and other agricultural resources.
In pastoral communities, livestock were valuable for their milk, reproduction, and economic contributions. Regularly slaughtering these animals for meat would have been impractical. Consequently, both humans and their dogs often relied heavily on renewable food sources.
Dogs that could digest starch more efficiently would have had a survival advantage in these environments. Over generations, natural selection favored genetic adaptations that improved their ability to utilize these foods.
Research examining dog populations around the world supports this relationship between agricultural history and the AMY2B gene.²
Dogs originating from regions with long histories of agriculture generally have more copies of the gene than dogs from regions where agriculture was historically limited.
For example, breeds such as German Shepherds, Border Collies, and English Springer Spaniels often have relatively high AMY2B copy numbers. By contrast, Greenland Dogs, Siberian Huskies, and certain other populations associated with non-agricultural environments tend to have fewer copies.
This variation is especially interesting because it demonstrates that dogs did not all evolve under identical dietary conditions. Their genetics reflect the environments in which their ancestors lived and the foods that were available to them.
The Ability to Digest Starch Does Not Mean Dogs Require a High-Starch Diet
This is perhaps the most important distinction to understand when interpreting this research.
An animal's ability to digest a particular food does not necessarily establish that the food is required for optimal health.
The AMY2B adaptation demonstrates that many dogs became better equipped to digest starch. It does not establish how much starch they should consume, whether a high-carbohydrate diet is preferable to a meat-based diet, or whether all dogs benefit equally from consuming grains.
Digestibility and nutritional requirements are two different things.
Dogs require specific nutrients, including essential amino acids, fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals, to maintain health. These requirements can be met through different combinations of appropriately formulated ingredients.
Although carbohydrates can provide a useful source of energy, dogs do not have an established minimum dietary requirement for starch in the same way that they have requirements for certain essential amino acids and fatty acids.
This does not mean carbohydrates are harmful. It simply means that their nutritional value should be evaluated in the context of the entire diet, rather than assuming they are either essential or inherently undesirable.
Furthermore, individual dogs may differ in their ability to digest and tolerate particular foods. Genetics, health status, digestive function, activity level, and other physiological factors can all influence how an individual responds to a diet.
The fact that dogs have adapted to consume a wide variety of foods should encourage us to consider individual differences rather than assume that every dog has identical nutritional needs.
What Does This Mean for Raw Feeding and Grain-Free Diets?
In her article, Beuchat challenges the popular belief that dogs should eat exclusively meat-based diets resembling those of wolves. She argues that raw feeding and grain-free diets are often promoted using evolutionary claims that overlook the dog's demonstrated adaptation to starch digestion.
There is a legitimate scientific point here.
It is inaccurate to suggest that domestic dogs are physiologically identical to wolves or that their digestive systems are incapable of processing grains.
However, the genetic evidence supporting starch digestion does not, by itself, demonstrate that a properly formulated raw diet is nutritionally inferior to a diet containing grains.
These are separate scientific questions.
The AMY2B research tells us something important about evolutionary adaptation. It does not directly compare the long-term health outcomes of dogs consuming balanced raw diets, cooked diets, or commercial kibble.
Likewise, the presence or absence of grains is not, by itself, a reliable measure of nutritional quality.
A diet containing grains can be nutritionally excellent or poorly formulated. The same is true of a grain-free diet. Raw diets also vary considerably in their nutritional completeness, ingredient quality, and safety.
Raw feeding requires particular attention to nutritional balance, while some grain-free formulations, especially those containing substantial amounts of pulses or potatoes, have raised concerns about diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy. These concerns warrant evaluating the complete formulation rather than simply categorizing diets as good or bad according to whether they contain grain.
Ultimately, the quality of a dog's diet depends on considerably more than whether the ingredients are raw, cooked, grain-free, or grain-inclusive.
Survival, Adaptation, and Optimal Health Are Not the Same Thing
There is another important consideration when we use evolutionary history to make decisions about modern canine nutrition.
Animals adapt to the conditions in which they live. Natural selection favors traits that improve survival and reproductive success in a particular environment. It does not necessarily produce the diet or lifestyle that maximizes an individual's long-term health.
If dogs living in agricultural communities survived and reproduced successfully while consuming significant quantities of grain, that tells us they were capable of utilizing those resources. It does not automatically tell us that the same diet would be ideal for every modern dog.
This distinction applies in the opposite direction as well. The fact that wolves evolved consuming primarily animal-based foods does not establish that domestic dogs must eat exactly like wolves.
Evolutionary history provides valuable information about biological capabilities, but it cannot answer every question about optimal nutrition. For that, we also need evidence from nutritional science, physiology, clinical research, and the health of individual animals.
Considering the Individual Dog
One of the most useful lessons from this research is that dogs exhibit meaningful biological variation.
A Siberian Husky whose ancestors lived in an environment where agriculture was largely impossible may have a different history of dietary adaptation than a Border Collie whose ancestors worked alongside shepherds in agricultural communities.
But breed ancestry is only part of the picture. Individual variation exists within breeds as well, and AMY2B copy number alone cannot tell us which diet is best for a particular dog.
When evaluating nutrition, it is worth considering the dog's age, activity level, body condition, digestive health, medical history, and response to different foods: Does the dog maintain a healthy weight and appropriate muscle condition? Is digestion comfortable and consistent? Are the skin and coat healthy? Is the diet complete and balanced for the dog's life stage?
These questions are more useful than relying exclusively on broad dietary labels or assumptions about what dogs historically ate.
When a dog has chronic digestive problems, skin issues, food sensitivities, or other health concerns, dietary decisions should be made thoughtfully and, when appropriate, with the guidance of a Certified Small Animal Naturopath or Nutritionist.
Moving Beyond Nutritional Ideology
The relationship between dogs and humans is extraordinary in part because dogs have demonstrated such remarkable adaptability. They have accompanied us into vastly different climates, landscapes, cultures, and ways of living. Their physiology reflects that shared history.
The AMY2B gene is one example of how profoundly domestication has influenced canine biology. But we should be careful not to turn a scientific discovery into a sweeping nutritional conclusion.
Understanding that dogs can digest starch is not the same as proving that they need a starch-heavy diet. Recognizing that wolves consume primarily animal-based foods does not mean that all domestic dogs should eat like wolves. Both conclusions oversimplify a much more complex biological reality.
The goal should not be to prove that one feeding philosophy is universally correct, but to understand the nutritional needs of the individual dog and meet those needs with a complete, balanced, appropriate, and safe diet.
The more we understand about canine evolution, genetics, and physiology, the better equipped we are to make thoughtful decisions about their care.
And perhaps one of the most valuable lessons from this research is that biological adaptability and optimal health are not necessarily the same thing.
References and Further Reading
-
Beuchat, C. (2018, May 31). A key genetic innovation in dogs: diet. Institute of Canine Biology.
https://www.instituteofcaninebiology.org/blog/a-key-genetic-innovation-in-dogs-diet -
Arendt, M., Cairns, K. M., Ballard, J. W. O., Savolainen, P., & Axelsson, E. (2016). Diet adaptation in dog reflects spread of prehistoric agriculture. Heredity.
Additional note: This article is intended for educational purposes and is not a substitute for individualized veterinary nutritional guidance. Homemade, raw, and other specialized diets should be formulated to meet established canine nutritional requirements, with appropriate attention to food safety.
